Strengths: High Volume, confidence inspiring cornering traction.
Weaknesses: May not be the fastest rolling tire.
Bottom Line:
I got this tire used at the local Bike co-op. It had around 85%-95% tread left and was just full of goatheads. I pulled them out , mounted it n a Mavic 217 tubed on the front of a Fisher Sugar. Awesome tire! This thing sticks in the Idaho high dessert loose moondust that happens around here after two months of no rain. I did not notice a vague transition to the cornering knobs as other reviewers had claimed. I also went south to Vegas for a couple of days riding and it performed as well in the rockier landscape .
Similar Products Used: IRC Mythos, Klein Death Grip, Panaracer Smole-Dart. WTB Moto-rapter
Bike Setup: 2002 Fisher Sugar, 98 Trek 930.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Dave
a Cross Country Rider
Date Reviewed: June 12, 2012
Strengths: Light, stable, good traction on climbs, If you can get comfortable with the drift in loose conditions the side knobs will really grab.
Weaknesses: These are expensive tires. I expected better durability.
Bottom Line:
I read the reviews about the weak sidewalls, but I figured the reviews were by some young guns tearing it up...no, wrong, this old and slow guy has ripped up two tires in the rocks of the Gila Nation Forest. Better to keep them on hard pack.
Favorite Trail: Signal Peak Challenge, Gila Natonal Forest
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Vdub
a All Mountain Rider
Date Reviewed: June 7, 2012
Strengths: Fast rolling and good cornering on hard packed dirt and slick rock.
Weaknesses: Too drifty and slippery on anything sandy, wet or loamy. Very tough to get traction using this as a rear tire on steep or sandy climbs. The sidewalls are a little weak and easy to pinch flat, as well as tear.
Bottom Line:
If you are riding mellow, smooth or hard packed single track these tires are decent. I only tried them because they came stock on my new bike but I switched tires as soon as possible (after tearing a sidewall). I would honestly Not recommend them for all mountain usage or anything with sand or jagged rocks, and there are far better tires for the money.
Similar Products Used: Maxxis High Roller and Ardent; Kenda Small block 8 and Nevegals; WTB Prowler XT and SS; etc
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
bipolarbear
a Cross Country Rider
from Colorado
Date Reviewed: June 28, 2011
Strengths: Good grip, lighter
Weaknesses: Super weak sidewalls
Bottom Line:
These came stock on my Pitch Pro. Read the reviews and figured that the guys tearing sidewalls were just riding really rocky trails aggressively. Not the case. I wouldn't buy these tires honestly.
I was riding the Colorado Trail in a section that was not rocky whatsoever. Blew out the sidewall who knows where. Put a hole that I could put my thumb through.
I only had these tire for a few months. Just got the bike at the end of last season, maybe 15 rides on the tires and they are shot.
Ride performance: Not very stable in the turn unless you really lean them over or run super low pressure. I can't, I'm a bigger guy.
Submitted by
Wally
a Weekend Warrior
from Ventura, CA
Date Reviewed: May 31, 2011
Strengths: Uhhhhhhh, can't really think of any strengths. Weight I guess (from what others are saying)?
Weaknesses: Weak sidewalls! I tore the rear sidewalls in several places after my first ride at Sandstone Peak (rocky trail). And they never felt solid while cornering or climbing off-camber stuff. They didn't grip the "dust-on-crust" conditions we have in SoCal. Replacing with Ol' Faithfuls tonight (Nevegals). Stay away from these tires if you ride similar rocky, hard-pack conditions
Bottom Line:
Don't buy. If they came on your bike, change em out before you hurt yourself.
Submitted by
ahracing
a Cross Country Rider
from Austin Texas USA
Date Reviewed: January 12, 2011
Strengths: Long lasting.All Trail usage
Weaknesses: None
Bottom Line:
Awesome tire used it downhilling on rear at Angel Fire then on to Frita,Four day tour hut to hut then on to Palo Dura State park.It climbs, it corners, awesome tire does not wash out.Very tough no slices.I have completely worn the rear out then put front on rear then put on a new front Eskar.I have ridden it all over central Texas at all the race courses.Run it tubeless at low pressures with no failures.Right now I am stocking up and will ride nothing else for now.
Similar Products Used: Specialized Purgatory 26 x 2.2
Bike Setup: Specialized Epic Marathon or Stumpjumper FSR
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Tom
a Weekend Warrior
from westchester
Date Reviewed: July 16, 2010
Strengths: Nice looking, reasonable weight, reasonable rolling resistance, good grip, sets up tubeless easily
Weaknesses: Totally suck on a 19mm rim
Bottom Line:
I bought these rims a long while back. I don't know if I ever rode them, but somehow they ended up on a set of crossmax XL's on one of my girlfriend's bikes. Not sure if she ever rode them. One day, I was eyeing them thinking "those might be pretty nice on one of my bikes". Put the wheels and tires on my Maveric ML7. Totally squirrely feeling tire, unable to ride with any confidence. Read in one of these reviews about how they aren't good on 19mm rims.
Mounted them on Easton AM Havoc rims (22mm) tubeless with stan's rhyno lite rim strips.
I have only ridden them once with this set-up, but they seem like really great tires.
Amazing how much difference a wider rim makes with a tire like this.
Similar Products Used: many: hutchinson, schwalbe, maxxis, kenda, etc.
Bike Setup: Banshee Morphine, 130 mm Manitou fork, Easton AM Havoc rims
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Tzvia
a Weekend Warrior
from Woodland Hills CA
Date Reviewed: June 19, 2010
Strengths: As a front tire, they may not be the fastest feeling, but they beat the Nevegal by a mile; grip well, hardpack to loose over hard and rocky conditions. They float well over sand up front and don't wander. Just keep up the gas and they dig right out in a straight line. Out here in So Cal, the tire that beats the sand is, in my opinion, a keeper. And so it is. I also have an S-Works on another bike, and they feel much the same. Haven't had the issues others have mentioned with 19mm rims, they fee just fine to me. Running them tubeless, they sealed up quikly with no fuss.
Weaknesses: A little slow feeling compared with the Wolverines I was using before, but the tradeoff is better cornering and better sand handling.
Bottom Line:
A good tire if you want a good all round dry condition tire (haven't tried it in damp/wet). Hardpack, loose, sand, rock gardens (our stuff is not usually sharp), roots, and rutted trails are no problem. Good cornering grip. So far, wearing well and have had no flats or cuts. I admit, I am a finesse XC/trail rider and will scan for the best line in the rough and not just bash through, but these tires are holding up well. Only 4 chilis, they are a bit pricey and maybe a tad slow feeling up front.
Similar Products Used: Wolverines, Tiogas, Nevegals, Weirwolfs.
Bike Setup: Giant Anthem W/XT XTR. Roval Control EL wheels.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
carl.watson
a Weekend Warrior
from leigh lancashire
Date Reviewed: July 2, 2009
Strengths: light grippy high volume easy to set up as tubeless with stans kit price
Weaknesses: very very weak and thin sidewalls.
Bottom Line:
superb in every respect until you encounter a sharp rock as i found out on my first ride out. a rock tore an inch long tear in the side wall. maybe bad luck but the sidewalls are very weak. wont use again as i had driven a long way and had a ride ruined. just fitted a pair of michelin mountain xtreme tubeless 2.5 tyres. a lot heavier but with reinforced sidewalls
Similar Products Used: bontrager jones michelin xtreme
Bike Setup: xtension explorer coil lyrik fox dhx4 ti spring specialized sx wheelset stans hope moto
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
dougifresh1
a Cross Country Rider
from Denver CO
Date Reviewed: June 13, 2009
Strengths: Rolls well
Weaknesses: Wears fast, so so grip in loose hardback on the rear.
Bottom Line:
Wears to quickly to consider buying again. It's light, but center knobs just melt away. Run @ 28lbs and still not great on mild wet or loose dirt over rock. Mounts easily and so far the sidewalls are ok, but only have been out a dozen times on them. Like the maxxis TNT's I'm running on the front.
Submitted by
denvech
a Weekend Warrior
from portland, or USA
Date Reviewed: May 1, 2009
Strengths: climbing, consistency, wear, lightweight, predictable and warn you before they fail in a corner, good drifting, specialized satisfaction guarantee
Weaknesses: Lightweight, sharp rock puncture prone, very poor inconsistent bite on soft loamy conditions
Bottom Line:
Good tire, pretty good all arounder but not great in the moist after winter needles and semi loose loamy trail conditions. They rock socks in harder pack. The cornering is fantastic and off camber exceptional. But if you have a thinner rim like a 19mm, the sidewalls are not strong enough to prevent rolling on the rim and squirmishness. Got a puncture prematurely, stans helped but still. If they lose grip, they tend to catch quick and warn you. I'm not going to replace my wheels, but I am getting different tires as the softer sidewalls are absolutely unnacceptable on my thinner rims. With the right rims though, I'd probably have a new favorite.
Similar Products Used: fire xc pro, mutano raptor, eskar armadillo, nevegal, cinder
Bike Setup: litespeed niota ti - decked out, 19mm wide cane creek zonos rim wheels
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Jerome
a Cross Country Rider
from Montreal, Quebec, CANADA
Date Reviewed: April 16, 2009
Strengths: Light weight for a tubeless-ready tire
Excellent grip, especially at low pressure
Nice volume for a 2.3 tire
Weaknesses: None to date
Bottom Line:
I've used this tire front and rear on my mullet/winter bikes, so they've seen mud as well as much snow and to say the least, I'm impressed. With the right pressure (under 30 psi) they grip like Tasmanian devils and track with the best in corners. I've been using the tires tubeless with 2 cups of Stan's and they held air fine, with just a few psi to add once in a while. Since march, I've mounted a Purgatory Control 2.2 in the rear to lighten a bit the rear wheel, but overall, the Eskar inspire confidence and are very well though-out for everything all-mountain and even light freeride, especially considering their price.
Similar Products Used: WTB Weirwolf 2.5
Specialized Purgatory Control 2Bliss 2.2
Bike Setup: Custom Specialized Pitch build from frame up
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
njoehawkeye
a Cross Country Rider
from Denver, CO, USA
Date Reviewed: February 4, 2009
Strengths: Freakin' Light, Compared to others this width. Great Traction, Low rolling resistance.
Weaknesses: Sidewalls seem flimsy, especially on the S-works, which I'm running on front. But hasn't been an issue yet.
Bottom Line:
Get these tires. MTB Action gave them rave reviews run tubeless and I figured I'd check out the hype. They're the real deal. I'm running the Control on Back to deflect some of the sharp ass rocks found on our front range trails. But really happy.
Also my riding buddy who got them first seems to almost keep up with me, until I got a set too. Seals up really well with Stan's too.
These might be a little pricey at retail, but I've seen them on ssale around Denver, But overall I think they're worth every penny. And the Wear seems alot better than my old nevegals so far (only three months).
Similar Products Used: Kenda Nevegal 2.35 Stick-E and DTC. WTB mutanoraptor
Bike Setup: Marin Wolf Ridge '07 Stock besides ghetto tubeless conversion with Eskar Control rear, S-works front. Oh and gold ODI Ruffians.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Jack Gold-Molina
a Cross Country Rider
from Seattle, WA
Date Reviewed: January 31, 2009
Strengths: Traction, low rolling resistance, climbs well, versatile
Bottom Line:
This is a great trail tire if you want something versatile that can handle damp singletrack with roots and rocks as well as dry, loose conditions. I normally like to use different tire combinations for the front and rear, but I have found that an Eskar rear works best with an Eskar front, rather that something else like a Nevegal front or a Velociraptor rear, so they work very well together. In more technical conditions that have a lot of roots and/or rocks, this might not be the best tire, but you could still get by with it. They stick to the trail very well and climb surprisingly well, even in wet and/or loose conditions. This is an excellent all-around trail tire. If you are looking for a more durable version of this tire, Specialized makes the Armadillo model also.
Similar Products Used: Kenda Nevegal front and rear; Panaracer Fire XC front and rear; MTB Velociraptor, older model Bontrager Jones, or Specialized Chunder rear with Nevegal or Panaracer Fire XC front
Bike Setup: Late 2007 Heckler, DT 5.1 rims with DT 340 hubs, Fox RP23 shock, 2007 Fox Float 140 forks
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
piccirilli
a Cross Country Rider
from Asheville, NC
Date Reviewed: December 11, 2008
Strengths: Light weight for a 2.4 tire- 700gr
Very, very low rolling resistance for all day rides
Low profile, not squishy like other tires in same class.
Hooks up well on turns. Predictable and stable.
Although not perfect, it does well in wet conditions considering the design for low rolling resistance
Weaknesses: Thin side walls but hey, what can you expect for a 700gr 2.4" tire? There has to be a compromise somewhere. If you are careful, not bombing through sharp rocks, or major hucking, it's a great all around tire.
Bottom Line:
I really liked this tire the first time I used it. 6 months later, I still love them. The nevegals stick better, but at a cost of rolling resistance. I would imagine the new Maxxis All Mountain Ardent tire would be more durable due to the thicker side walls, with extra weight +150grams per tire. I would give the Ardent a try if you need something with thicker sidewalls. Otherwise use these, because the tread design is the best I've found so far for All Mountain. I am 170lbs, run 30lbs pressure and they serve me well up to 4' drops.