Strengths: Incredible grip, strong sidewalls, beefy, lightweight, great rubber compound, good price.
Weaknesses: Wears pretty fast but i would not expect it to last for a long time since it is a very soft tire.
These tires rock! They grip like crazy and i can really trust them, and if i think i will slip off some roots or offcamber rock, they will stick to it and give me a smooth ride.
They dont roll that well, but i dont care as long as they have such good grip.
When all mountain/trail riding i use 23 psi, no pinch flats, just awesome grip.
If youre looking for bad weather trail tires, get these and dont look back.
Bike Setup: 2011 Specialized Enduro with XTR Trail brakes, MM tires, commandpost ++
a Weekend Warrior
from Lincolnshire UK
Date Reviewed: February 7, 2011
Strengths: Grip, burlyness
2.5 freeride single ply trailstar compound
Super grip, the side nobbles are actually sticky to the touch so you can lean like mad on them. the sidewalls are quite tough and make mounting them a bit tricky. I don't think that pinch flats are going to be an issue unless you regularly downhill through jagged rock gardens - in which case, get the downhill versions! The rolling resistance is higher than nobby nics I use for cross country, but less than the nevegals I just took off.
Similar Products Used: high roller super tacky, nevegal, big betty, fat albert
Bike Setup: IH 6.6
a Weekend Warrior
from Sants Cruz, CA
Date Reviewed: October 2, 2010
Strengths: fantastic grip, confidence inspiring, no pinch flats even with 30psi, did i mention grip everywhere, sizing is true
Weaknesses: they grip like crazy, so rolling resistance leaves a bit to be desired.
proabibly the best tire ever, i have spent tons of cash and countless hours on Soooo many different tires and these muddy mary's simply kick a$$, if only the rolling resistance was just a scoesh better it would be the most perfect tire possible imo. I also friggin love the new nobby nic's amazing tire but sidewall strength will allow pinch flats when bombing.
Similar Products Used: maxxis ardent-kenda nevegal-spesh eskar-conti MK & RQ-wtb weirwolf lt and new
Bike Setup: 2010 S-works Enduro set up for AM/FR
2009 Trek Session 88
from San Diego Boise Id
Date Reviewed: July 18, 2010
Strengths: Grip, control, diversity, construction
Weaknesses: Guey glueys wear fast but AMAZING race tire
Guey glueys wear fast but stick amazing and well worth the money when you need to pin it..... Performance outweighs the wear and cost if needed...
Traction is definently 85% from mud being a 1 and bone dry being a 100. It hooks up and sticks total control at every turn with no questionable spots on it...
Ive ridden snow, mud from the NW to SOcal from 5 degrees to 105 degrees,,, Tire is amazing and STRONGLEY recomend it...
Strengths: I've found these tires very grippy in wet conditions on roots, rocks, and mud. I've run them at the min pressure without getting pinch flat and the sidewalls with snakeskin are holding up great. If you let the tires do they're job and keep off the brakes you'll be practically glued to the trail. The 2.5's are beastly too.
Weaknesses: The gooey gluey is showing some wear and tear after a few weekends of DH stuff, mostly wet conditions. I'm trying to makes these last so I'm switching them out depending on conditions.
Another great tire from Schwalbe, a bit specific for conditions, but it's the right tool for the job. A point or two off for price.
Similar Products Used: Schwalbe Fat Albert (uni-directional). Fat Albert Front/Rear combo, Tioga DH.
Bike Setup: IH 6.6 mostly stock.
Torsten ohne "h"
a Weekend Warrior
from from the middle of nowhere in Germany
Date Reviewed: April 13, 2009
Strengths: - grip on wet conditions, even snow and ice
- self cleaning at muddy conditions
- they "warn" you, before you get in trouble
Weaknesses: - the gooeygluey wears down fast at roads and trails with a lot of small stones
i bought the muddy mary 2.35 with the gooeygluey compound as "winter tires" for my AM bike.
they perform great from october till eastern in the wet and muddy forrest. great self cleaning, no proplem to go uphill at wet grass or roots.
even in the snow and on ice the soft and grippy gooeygluey compound performs well. sure, not as good as spikes, but good and save enough to have some winter fun.
now, since it is getting wormer i replaced them. the soft compound wears out at stones and streets and i like to "save" them as my favroite winter tire.
Similar Products Used: Maxxis High Roller and Minion DH UST
Bike Setup: Demo 7 II 2008
a Weekend Warrior
from Leipzig Eastgermany
Date Reviewed: July 19, 2008
Strengths: good for intended use
Weaknesses: it cant do everything ;.)
I have the freeride version (folding bed) in 2.5 " size, Gooeygluey compound in front and Triple in back.
These tires are really big! Check your frame before, the are not only 67mm wide, but also very high! The weight is just under 1000g each, about 100grams more than BigBetty. Thats ok.
The grip on loose soil, mud and wet stones/roots is outstanding.
When it comes to hardpack or flat stones/tarmac, the tire is easy to pedal, but the giant knobs will roll over slightly in corners and give you an unstable feel.
The sheer size of the tire gives a plush feel when hitting hard over ocks and stuff. I didnt have a flat yet, but I think for downhilling the DH version will be safer.