Home | Reviews | Hub | Hope

Hope Pro 2 Evo Front Hub

3.5/5 (2 Reviews)
MSRP : $143.99


  • Store Price
    Buy Now
    Buy Now
    Buy Now

Product Description

Hopes Pro 2 has


Review Options:  Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating

Reviews 1 - 2 (2 Reviews Total)

User Reviews

Overall Rating:2
Value Rating:3
Submitted by Volker a Cross Country Rider

Date Reviewed: April 22, 2015

Strengths:    Nice finish, rather cheap, easy to convert from standard quick release axles (5mm) to QR20, easy to get to the bearings.

Weaknesses:    Inherent design flaw that puts axial load onto to inner bearing races that will lead to premature failures. Rather slim and expensive bearings of type 6(1)804 2RS as required by the conversion option.

Bottom Line:   
After about 3 1/2 years of moderate riding (approx 10'000km), one of the two front bearings (S6804 2RS, #10 in the explosion plot found at http://cdn.hopetechnology.netdna-cdn.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/ProIIEvoFrontExploded.pdf) made klicking noises and was generally running a bit rough. After removing the two 9mm RWS spacers (#4), I could move the centre tube (#2) with almost no force using my index finger. That kind of loose fit could have created axial force on the inner bearing reals, leading to early failure.

Hope support writes back: "The Pro 2 Evo front hub is designed so that the centre tube is slightly loose when the wheel is out of the fork. This is to enable it to be moved to the side, exposing the bearings inner race so that it can be drifted out when it need replacing. Once the wheel is tightened into the fork the centre tube becomes tight as the hub is pulled together." which I consider an alibi statement.

Every halfways talented mechanic can use a bearing puller without a slack spacer tube. If necessary, the manufacturer could have added two little notches at opposite sides of the diameter (one end is sufficient) of the tube as a possibility to place your drift there.

I rather believe that the conversion option is the culprit and the Pro 2 Evo was designed with a focus on customers with a QR20 axle. The downside of this is, that the bearing needs to be unnecessarily large and thin for the 5mm quick release option which impairs load capacities (dynamic load rating: 3.95kN, static load rating: 2.3kN) in comparison to a more compact one. Not to mention leverage effects.

Ontop of that, the QR20 axle system works differently in one major respect: It doesn't produce any axial force during the clamping procedure by design, identical to most motorcycle wheel axles. So as long as axial clearance between the QR20-standard fork legs is not way out of spec, no mentionable static axial load is applied to the inner bearing races.

With the quick release system, however, you're having several kN of clamping force to keep the wheel in place, which is quite considerable if you know the E-module (aka. Young's modulus) of an aluminum spacer tube that has an ID of 20mm and ~1mm of wall thickness. Even, if it would be a tight fit, which it in fact isn't - for dubious reasons.

To acount for those forces, normally a C3 spec bearing is chosen. For a 61804 bearing (dimensions 20x32x7mm) the C3 tolerance adds about 20um of axial clearance and hence about 10x that number of radial clearance. This would be 200um or 0.2mm, more than enough to take any compressions, be it because of manufacturing tolerances, the clamping force, because of temperature differences or bearings not ideally seated. But that choice obviously was not the case.

Hope says: "Also, bearing life is subjective, usage/conditions etc, and it would not be unusual for a bearing to need replacing after 10,000Km over 3 1/2 years.".

I translate: A best case life expectancy (did I mention, that the hub is in mint shape, OEM grease not contaminated, aluminum spacer tube not corroded and bearing seals/O-rings like new?) of a Hope Pro 2 Evo hub being advertised with "Unsurpassed reliability" (http://www.hopetech.com/product/pro-2-evo-front-hub) is about 3 1/2 years and 10'000km of casual riding. Good to know. I guess DT-Swiss would be pretty embarassed to say something likewise about their products.

So here's what to do if your Hope hub fails like mine:

1. Manufacture a stainless steel spacer tube (AD 22mm, thickness 1mm or whatever fits) of correct length, i.e. one that doesn't flop around between the bearings.

2. Replace the bearings by standard steel 6(1)804 2RS C3 from FAG/INA/SKS/Koya or whatever manufacturer you can get your hands on. Don't pay 10 bucks or more for a single stainless steel bearing. It's not worth it.

3. Revise your hub (pretty easy to do), grease well and keep an eye on what happens.

I wouldn't be very surprised if the result holds up much longer that one meagre year beyond end of warranty.

Expand full review >>

Duration Product Used:   3.5yrs

Price Paid:    $65.00

Purchased At:   bike-mailorder.de

Similar Products Used:   DT-Swiss Onyx and Cerit. Varous cone bearing hubs from Shimano that all sucked because the needed constant adjustment and failed nevertheless.

Bike Setup:   DIY hardtail with Marzoccho Drop-Off Z3, 180/160mm Shimano disk brakes, Syntace P6 seatpost, Spank Subrosa rims, Sapim force spokes, Shimano XT 3x9 HT-II crankset and drive and Kinesis Ultralite frame.

Overall Rating:5
Value Rating:5
Submitted by Allrotor13b a All Mountain Rider

Date Reviewed: October 12, 2012

Strengths:    Ease of service
Lack of need for servicing =o)
Ease of conversion
Durability
Colors
Price


Weaknesses:    More color options? How about green, orange or purple?

Bottom Line:   
Anything made by Hope is fantastic. You will likely never have any need to fiddle with your Hope hubs, but if you do, the parts and tools are readily available and the servicability of these are super-simple.

Expand full review >>

Favorite Trail:   Any one

Duration Product Used:   Years

Price Paid:    $185.00

Purchased At:   Wiggle.com

Similar Products Used:   DT, Hadley

Bike Setup:   Trek 3900 (Hardtail)
Marzocchi 2012 55CR Fork
Hope Headset
Hope DH Stem
Answer Pro Taper AM .5" Risers
Hope PRO II evo SP Hubs on Mavic EX721 rims (Hope Hoops)
Shimano Saint (M810) Crank
Hope Stainless Bottom Bracket
Hope 40T Chainring
e*13 LG1+ Guide
Shimano XT (M770) Shifter
Shimano Saint (M810) Rear Derailleur
Shimano Saint Cassette (11-28)
Shimano XT Chain
Shimano XT (M785) Brakes w/ 203mm Front, 180mm Rear IceTech rotors
Kenda Nevegal 2.5 Front, 2.35 Rear

Reviews 1 - 2 (2 Reviews Total)

Review Options:  Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating

 




   

MTBR on Facebook