Bontrager's RL MTB shoe is the perfect companion for your epic trail rides. Rugged, efficient, incredibly comfortable, and more about epic adventure than all-out speed, the RL MTB is plenty light and stiff thanks to a Bronze Series Composite sole that helps put the power to the pedals. It's also built for long-wearing durability, featuring a TPU toe cap and tough medial and lateral side mud guards. It's all-day comfort and all-day support for all day on the mountain.
I ripped open the package like an overzealous kid at his birthday party and the contents spilled onto the garage floor. “Wow” I thought, cool-looking shoes, silver uppers with an orange plaid trim around the ankle. They seemed reasonably light weight and the three strap system looked typical – two Velcro straps and one buckle-type strap. Also in the package were the optional toe cleats and the tool for tightening them. Continue reading →
Strengths: Very comfortable. Super easy to get in and out of , plenty of toe room and not narrow squeezing your feet fatiguing them . Stiff enough sole to get you moving and keep you moving, good tread pattern when it comes time to hump up the trail.
Weaknesses: None so far, these are the 2012 edition which the rep says they did improvements from last years model.
Bottom Line:
I upgraded to these shoes from Sete Element MTB shoe which is a outstanding shoe for beginners starting out clipless. But after 1 year of riding with those shoes I realized my feet needed a better shoe overall . Something not so narrow, comfortable and with better securing to my feet. The Bontrager RL Mountain fits my requirements and needs for an "Upgrade Shoe". Also the Trek store rep gave me 10% off for buying them, total cost was less than $140.00 .
Strengths: cost, on the wider side inside, stiff sole
Weaknesses: eSole insoles that are compatible are costly, noticed threads coming loose, etc. after modest amount of use, fit isn't for everyone
Bottom Line:
The price is right for these shoes but they don't work for everyone. I wear a 46 but these were a little too large for my foot, while the next lower size was definitely too small even with a super-thin sock. No half sizes is a bummer. With the shoes being slightly large, I figured no sweat, I'll wear them during the shoulder season -- wear a winter boot is too hot but you need a thick sock to keep the feet warm -- but they do not keep water out. Not a problem in the summer, when if sometimes feels good to get some water on your feet in a stream crossing, but not good in the late fall or winter/spring.
The other issue was the inside fit was strange -- had a lump or something that pushed on the side of my foot. Don't fit as well as Shimano or Sidi.
Finally, the construction quality is suspect -- though they're nice a lightweight, I can't see them holding up well for more than a season of hard use. So I gave up on them and went with Shimano -- much happier.
Strengths: Lightweight, Breathable, easy to get in and out of, STYLE!
Weaknesses: Adjustments, Fit
Bottom Line:
I bought these at a LBS Tent Sale a few weeks ago and have about 10 rides in. I like how comfortable the shoes are to wear. They breathe nicely and have super stiff soles. These are the Orange/Plaid model. My only complaint would be that I constantly have to adjust the fit on a long ride; they stretch out and become loose way too easy. IMO
My feet do not become nearly as fatigued and get 'hot spots' as they did in my old Shimano's.
Not sure I'd buy another pair, but for the price, they are a heck of an upgrade!
Strengths: Good stiff sole, comfortable for long rides.
Weaknesses: The plastic soles can be very very slippery indoors. The plastic buckles seem fragile. I bent the metal that holds it in a crash. It still works, but I'm not sure if it will survive another crash.
Bottom Line:
Good shoes, good value. I'll shop around when I have to pick up a new pair, but I would consider them again.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
slomak
a Cross Country Rider
from boulder colorado usa
Overall, Bontrager hit the mark! Recommended by racer who has over two hard seasons with shoes, and still going strong. Have not been disappointed. Good fit (even on steep loose hike sections), truly feel the carbon under foot difference; light and ventilated. Can not beat the price for this quality. Going into season two and nothing is showing any excessive wear. I feel like a rep for Bontrager, but not so-just a great shoe!
Submitted by
Stevuke
a Weekend Warrior
from Bergenfield, NJ, USA
Date Reviewed: May 7, 2011
Strengths: Light weight, well ventilated, holds your foot tightly to the carbon fiber sole for excellent power transfer
Weaknesses: crappy plastic buckle. plastic release already broke. the plastic strap is about to break off at the end (it'll still work though.. just shorter)
Bottom Line:
I enjoy using the shoe and I love riding clipless.. this is my first mountain shoe. I'm riding on CB Mallets.
It's light, stiff, great treads and decent for walking. Very breathable.. I can feel the breeze on my foot. This shoe is nice and efficient.. looks cool too.
But the plastic strap, buckle and release are for crap.
Don't get me wrong, I love how you can ratchet the buckle to make it fit super perfect.. that part works well.. but it breaks way too easy.
Submitted by
Rucker
a Weekend Warrior
from Auburn, Alabama, USA
Date Reviewed: December 3, 2010
Strengths: Super light
Comfy
Great looks
Super breathable
Weaknesses: Really only the ratchet strap. Its made of plastic and kinda cheap.
Bottom Line:
Awesome shoe overall. They are light, comfy, and overall a good shoe. I dont have any problems with the shoe being too loose, but I have to have the straps all the way tight. One of the best things I think is how breathable they are. I dont sweat at all in these. Highly recommend.
Submitted by
Brett Houser
a Cross Country Rider
from Long Beach, CA
Date Reviewed: December 3, 2010
Strengths: Lite in weight, great arch support, good looks (silver)!
Weaknesses: Buckle seems some what flimsy, but works well. Buckle strap could be 1" longer.
Bottom Line:
I have been using these shoes now for approx. 3 months and I have had no issues with them. It's a well made shoe, lite, firm, and not bad looking. I normaly wear a size 11, but had to go with a 44.5 (10 1/2)
Bike Setup: HiFi Pro 29er (2010 model) Full XT componets.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
bnbski
a Cross Country Rider
from St Louis, MO
Date Reviewed: October 24, 2010
Strengths: Durable and comfortable.
Weaknesses: Could have a slightly wider toe box.
Bottom Line:
Have used these shoes hard for last 18 months. Completed BT Epic 55 mile mtb race yesterday, same race last year and other xc races plus 100's of personal rides. Shoe has never let me down, ratchet system can be adjusted by clicking and also by changing the screw location for larger/smaller feet.
Bike Setup: Scott Scale 29 Elite - stock with Time ATAC pedals.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Crisis
a Cross Country Rider
from Orlando, FL, USA
Date Reviewed: September 7, 2010
Strengths: Good looks
Weaknesses: Where to begin. I broke the cheap plastic ratchet thing on my left shoe the first time I went down on it. Unlike most other shoes that have some kind of metal ratchet system that is as flat against the shoe this design goes with cheap plastic that sticks out pretty far and is almost impossible to not land on.
Another problem I'm having with the ratchet system is that the leather strap has stretched to the point where it's no longer as tight as I need it to be around my foot. I'm experiencing stretching with the two Velcro straps as well.
Bottom Line:
Don't waste your money on this shoe. It looks nice but at this price there are many other options for a better shoe. The flimsy ratchet and stretching straps kill this shoe for me.
Weaknesses: ratchet buckle strap unreplaceable, velcro tabs stretched out
Bottom Line:
Have had these for about a year and half and I still enjoy them. They are more durable than they look, and they look pretty cool. The ratchet strap is all chewed up now, and that is not replaceable. The velcro middle and bottom strap have a little stretch to them and now that they are stretched out, it is hard to get the shoes really tight. Overall, they have worn well and been comfortable, so I cannot complain. Good power transfer with the carbon soles with just enough flex to be nice to walk in.
Submitted by
Kingfsher
a Weekend Warrior
from Charleston, SC USA
Date Reviewed: August 3, 2010
Strengths: Great fit, affordable, comfortable!!!, firm sole, & light!!!
Weaknesses: Feels more like a cleat walking on concrete/asphalt & hardwood floors. (but it is a cleat so I wouldn't dock them any points)
Bottom Line:
Great shoe. Comfortable, feels like my Brooks running shoes. They are LIGHT!!! very affordable. Clicked straight into my pedals w/o any issues. I wish they weren't click clacky like cleats are on artificial surfaces but thats not really a real issue to be concerned about when buying a mountain bike shoe. Highly recommend!
Bike Setup: 2011 Trek 4300 Stock w/ Shimano M324 SPD pedals and Bontrager Carbon Fibre bar ends.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
DangerDave86
a Cross Country Rider
from Reston, VA, USA
Date Reviewed: July 21, 2010
Strengths: Carbon fiber power plate, light weight, wide toe box, breathable, and price.
Weaknesses: The ratchet seems chintzy, but does not pose as a huge issue so far.
Bottom Line:
I have been extremely impressed with this shoe so far. Only put about seven hours in them but they are performing better than I expected. With the carbon fiber plate you can really put the power down, unlike with some of the other shoes I have had. And if you have a wider foot than most people this is the shoe for you, it has excellent arch support, breathable and a large toe box. The only downside I can see is the ratchet, it seems sub-par and may break in a wreck but besides that this is a great shoe you can feel comfortable in for those long all day rides.
Similar Products Used: Specialized Comp Mountains, Pearl Izumi Select MTB.
Bike Setup: Trek mountain/cross
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Jeremy
a Cross Country Rider
from Fort Kent, Maine. USA
Date Reviewed: April 1, 2010
Strengths: They looked good in the window...
Weaknesses: For the second year, Bontrager/Trek fails to address the crappy racheting buckle, after some pretty critical reviews on-line and in print. The buckle works poorly and the strap cant be adjusted for length.
The eSole insole is gimicky and worthless. In the end, it seemed like a ploy to get you to go to eSOle.com and buy a real insole from them.
Bottom Line:
I'm pissed that Bontrager has disregarded customer feedback and continued to produce crap. Bottom line? I won't buy another item from this company, ever!
Bitterly yours,
JG