Review Options:
Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating |
|
Reviews 1 - 15 (40 Reviews Total)
|
| Next 15 |
User Reviews
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Jonathan
a Cross Country Rider
from IsraelDate Reviewed: February 18, 2008
Strengths: Worked well for 6 monthsWeaknesses: The middle chainring started to cause a lot of chiansucks after a half a year. Very disappointed.Bottom Line: I should have read this page before I got the crank it would have saved me a lot of money!!!!!!
Shimano did a big scam here to make more money!!!!!!!!!!!!
Duration Product Used: 1 Year
Purchased At: CTC Israel
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
spiro vagenas
from DenmarkDate Reviewed: September 7, 2007
Strengths: 22 chainring does the jobWeaknesses: 44 chainring very short lifeBottom Line: Anything else than a XT 44 chainring. There are simply put, no benefits with this chainring. This is also the impression I get from my local bike shop. I have been through a few of these chainrings now and I have never come across a chainring this soft.
Favorite Trail: koeki
Duration Product Used: More than 3 years
Purchased At: original component
Similar Products Used: no name brands
Bike Setup: koga-miyata tls
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Zane
a Cross Country Rider
from Henderson, NVDate Reviewed: July 26, 2007
Strengths: NoneWeaknesses: Skips like a 5yr old girl.Bottom Line: Do not buy this product. After 10 months of trouble shooting, banging my knees on the bars and going over the bars, I learned last week that Shimano knows there is a design flaw in the 2006 model and they will do a recall replacement if you complain. However, they are not offering up this information to the bike shops. If I catch the Shimano rep in my LBS, I'm going to make him feel the pain I've felt due to this f#$@ing piece of crap.
Favorite Trail: Cottonwood Trails
Duration Product Used: 1 Year
Purchased At: Local Bike Shop
Similar Products Used: Shimano LX
Bike Setup: Klein Atittude Race frame, Mavic wheels, Shimano XT group, Easton EA70 bar/stem/post
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Brendan
a Cross Country Rider
from Wollongong, AustraliaDate Reviewed: June 28, 2007
Strengths: Shifts OK.Weaknesses: Chain skips on it without much wear.Bottom Line: Abyssmal. Worst middle chainring I have ever used. Replaced chainring on XT crank which wore early with another XT in October of last year.
It skipped from the outset, everyone in the bike shop I bought it at, and the people I rode with looked at me like I was a mechanically inept idiot. Had replaced chain and cassette with SRAM ones at time of change over, so replaced those as I thought it would improve going back to all Shimano setup. Wrong. Chain skipped going up a short hard climb, went over the bars, landed on a jagged burnt out stump, was cut and gouged profusely. Found out these things had problems/issues even when new, replaced with cheap BBB chainring, and have not had a problem since.
I can't believe Shimano could put something this bad on the market. I had complete faith in them, to the point of replacing everything but this chainring, until told of these issues by the LBS after they'd made some enquiries. Looking back it's probably even worse a situation than the crappy XTR chainrings they made, at least those weren't complete crap from the outset.
Favorite Trail: Anything local
Duration Product Used: 6 months
Purchased At: LBS
Similar Products Used: RaceFace, BBB, TruVativ, Blackspire.
Bike Setup: Blur LT, Nixon fork, XO shifters and rear derailleur, LX front, CrossMax XL wheels, Juicy carbon brakes, Maverick seatpost.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
John
a Cross Country Rider
from Austin, TXDate Reviewed: April 16, 2006
Weaknesses: Unbelieveably cheesy. Started skipping early and after a year it died, put on a brand new one and that one skipped too. Replaced it with a Salsa for half the price and it skips no more.Bottom Line: Not worth the price, wears down too quick and skips under torque
Favorite Trail: Barton Creek Greenbelt
Duration Product Used: 1 Year
Purchased At: With bike
Similar Products Used: Salsa chainring ($20)
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
pierre bourgon
a Cross Country Rider
from cornwall, ON, CanadaDate Reviewed: December 24, 2005
Strengths: smooth shifteing, bombproofWeaknesses: rapid wearBottom Line: these are good cranks, not especially durable though. If you have a problem with gear wear with any aluminum chainring just find a steel replacement. usually this is a problem with the two smallest chainrings. just make sure it has chain pick-ups (ramps, pins) like the old chainring. chainsuck, never happened. most aluminum chainrings will 3000-6000 miles before they are shark-finned.
Favorite Trail: any trail I find
Duration Product Used: More than 3 years
Purchased At: on bike
Similar Products Used: STX RC(cheap durable steel), truivat-s,s,Al
Bike Setup: no suspention
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Nigel S
a Cross Country Rider
from Dublin, IrelandDate Reviewed: November 4, 2005
Strengths: works fine for 4 monthsWeaknesses: they suck...Bottom Line: if u want a product that will last...don't bother with these.
They worked fine for 4 or 5 months but then the chainsuck began....mystery bent teeth and now 3 broken teeth on my granny ring?? very strange indeed!
i had deore cranks for 4 years and i never had a problem. it doesn't make sense that a product that costs more is far worse...
Shimano....Get ur act together
Favorite Trail: anything technical
Duration Product Used: 1 Year
Price Paid:
$150.00
Purchased At: as part of my bike
Similar Products Used: 2000 deore cranks
Bike Setup: Merlin Malt 2, magura asgard forks, full XT kit
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
jason
a Cross Country Rider
from los angelesDate Reviewed: August 21, 2005
Strengths: Tough one, they seem to work if the conditions are perfect...u know, the moon is aligned with the sun crap...Weaknesses: In short...one year...went thru 3 rings...many broken teeth, and the chain suck...omg...if only my girlfriend would suck this much i would have married her a long time agoBottom Line: I've tried to stand by shimano...repeatedly forking out the cash to replace what I thought was rider error. Spending hours cleaning my chain, rings, cogs, ... stopping and hiking thru mud/water in hopes to keep my drive train clean and suck free....no luck. And when these rings dont suck, they break...forgetaboutit. I recently moved on to race face and very happy, no complaints.
Favorite Trail: Peak, suicide
Duration Product Used: 1 Year
Similar Products Used: race face,
Bike Setup: Enduro Pro
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Eben
from Palo Alto, CA, USADate Reviewed: June 21, 2005
Strengths: None. Sometimes possibly to pedal over parking lots if there are no puddles.Weaknesses: Chain suck from day one on new Epic Marathon. Skipping on hills. Can't handle any mud or water. Complete junk.Bottom Line: Get anything but these Shimano XT chain rings. Not sure what I'm going to try now, but need to figure something else out as I can not pedal up hills due to severe constant chain suck. Very frustrating! These get 0 flamin chilis all around.
Duration Product Used: 3 months
Purchased At: OffRamp
Similar Products Used: 9 years of same chain rings on specialized pro before buying this new bike this year. If I had the old chain rings I would put them on in a second.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Jason
a Cross Country Rider
from Johnson City, TNDate Reviewed: June 14, 2005
Strengths: Reasonably lightWeaknesses: I got the crankset at pricepoint in April of last year and the teeth were mangled on the middle and small rings before the summer was over.Bottom Line: These things are junk
Duration Product Used: 1 Year
Price Paid:
$100.00
Purchased At: Pricepoint.com
Similar Products Used: LX
Bike Setup: Santa Cruz Superlight
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
James Taylor
a Racer
from UKDate Reviewed: December 16, 2004
Strengths: Shifts well when chain is not jammed.Weaknesses: Chain suck on the middle ring after 1 hours use, it is constantly getting pulled up behind the chain set when pedaling along normally. Replacement chain did not help.Bottom Line: 2004 XT middle rings are not fit for purpose, 1 out of 5 is far to generous. My problem is not isolated and I think Shimano should recall this product.
The problem only gets worse with use, after no more than 20 hours I couldn't even ride across a car park without it sucking up.
Replaced the middle ring with a Middleburn, now waiting for Madison to refund the cost under warranty.
Favorite Trail: Pennines
Duration Product Used: Less than 1 month
Purchased At: On bike from Keswick MTB
Similar Products Used: Old XT (bomb proof) Pace, Sugino, Campagnolo.
Bike Setup: 2004 Specialized Epic Marathon.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Luke
from Sudbury, MADate Reviewed: July 12, 2004
Strengths: Shifts wellWeaknesses: Doesn't last long, granny wears out causing chainsuck under stressBottom Line: I'm frustrated - after dealing with the mis-aligned frames that the sugars had I have now had two granny rings wear out causing chainsuck under stress. I don't get it. My 11 year-old hardtail has its' original rings on it. Reading the other reviews I see many folks had problems with the middle ring. My issue is with the granny. Any suggestions on more durable rings that will fit the four-arm setup?
Duration Product Used: More than 3 years
Bike Setup: 2002 Sugar 3+, XT front and rear deraillereurs, Hollowtech XT crank and rings
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Roberto
a Weekend Warrior
from Albuquerque, NMDate Reviewed: July 10, 2004
Strengths: Light, smooth shifting - but who cares if they can't hold your chain when you most need them to.Weaknesses: NOT MADE FOR ALL BIKES! BE CAREFUL!
Not compatible with some full suspension bikes.
I have Giant NRS and the middle ring would not hold the chain when the rear suspension engaged - even when the ring was brand new. I replace the middle ring with a much less "engineered" ring (and much less expensive) and the problem went away completely. Shimano should offer us some rings that get it done the old fashion way - with big beautiful TEETH.
Bottom Line: Keep it simple stupid - these rings are not mountain bike rings. Until they change the design, I will never buy these rings again.
Favorite Trail: King Cedidro
Duration Product Used: 1 Year
Price Paid:
$50.00
Purchased At: performancebike.com (?)
Bike Setup: Giant NRS with XT drivetrain
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Matt
a Weekend Warrior
from Bracknell, BerkshireDate Reviewed: March 12, 2004
Strengths: weight, looks and the price I paid for them.Weaknesses: chainsuck on granny wheel and middle ring in muddy or wet conditions.Bottom Line: I decided to get these instead of middleburn as they were being sold at half-price. They performed well for my trip across France, but off roading, any hint of mud and these things suck big time. Needless to say, I am ditching these and buying some boone chainrings. I also found the XT levers to be cheap and nasty too.
Duration Product Used: 1 Year
Price Paid:
$75.00
Purchased At: Halfords
Similar Products Used: LX, and others
Bike Setup: Dean Colonel, Hope hubs and front disc, avid v-brakes (rear), shimano XT gearing througout.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Jack
from the netherlandsDate Reviewed: November 5, 2003
Strengths: Shimano XT 2003 cranks are okWeaknesses: second chainring causes chainsuck all the time in wet/muddy circumstancesBottom Line: In general I have no complaints about the shimano XT products. Bust the second chainring really sucks. When it's only a little bit rainy and muddy outside I 'll get chainsucks all the time. I have tried other chains (KMC) but still had chainsucks. Though I only have riden 600 kilometre with these chainrings I am goiing to replace them for BBB.
I expected more quality from shimano's second-best MTB group. (Shimano refunds are welcome)
Favorite Trail: Havelte
Duration Product Used: 6 months
Similar Products Used: BBB
Bike Setup: Ridley xt/xtr, duke, crossmax, fast fred 2.35
|
Reviews 1 - 15 (40 Reviews Total)
|
| Next 15 |
Review Options:
Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating |