Review Options:
Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating |
|
Reviews 1 - 15 (15 Reviews Total)
| |
User Reviews
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Marcy
a Cross Country Rider
from New York, NYDate Reviewed: December 8, 2000
Strengths: Comfortable
Gets a lot of staresWeaknesses: From long wear-and-tear, the stiching around the fabric in in center of the saddle wore off and actually started to hurt. Besides the stiching wearing out, the sides of the seat where your legs constantly rub from the round motion of your pedal strokes wore a bit as well and got small cracks in the leather.
Another weakness is the color, I think yellow is a VERY loud color, especially with my blue mountain bike.Bottom Line: Comfortable until the stitching starts to wear off!!!
Duration Product Used: More than 3 years
Price Paid:
$85.00
Similar Products Used: Selle Italia Trans Am (Great seat)
Bike Setup: GT LTS 2 with XTR components, Kore stem, M646 pedals
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Skippy
a
from Park Ridge, IL, USADate Reviewed: March 27, 2000
Strengths: Light, Good shape, ComfortableWeaknesses: Yellow makes dirt show up more (oh boo hoo).Bottom Line: Damn nice seat for men and women. Same thing as the Race Day just minus Kevlar sides. Works well with my skinny @$$ and was a BIG improvement over my SDG Ventura. Like the shorter nose on it (great for bumpy singletrack and less of a chance of getting smacked in the package when riding standing), the extended down sides nicely cover the rails eliminating any posibility of rub, and its good and light (240g). Got a great deal on it, the yellow provides a little eye-candy. Great seat for men or women.
Duration Product Used: Less than 1 month
Similar Products Used: SDG Ventura
Bike Setup: XCR 4000, Ritchey Logic Pro Stem, Thomson Elite Seatpost, Avid 1.0OL Levers, Avid 20 brakes, Ritchy Clipless Pedals, Wildgripper Lite S Tires, XT All Around.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
CatDaver
a Cross-Country Rider
from Richmond,VADate Reviewed: July 24, 1999
Strengths:
Looks are eyecatchingWeaknesses:
Feels very uncomfortable so it sits in the closet with a few other saddles I hated.Bottom Line: At first the saddle felt ok for a few months, but than doing longer road rides made me hate the saddle. I think its the middle gel part, because I started hurting badly in certain parts. Waste of my money and I wouldn't recommend it,but everybody is different in their comfort. Just gathering dust, I prefer Specialized's Body Geometry saddles and Giro's Vitesse.I am never totally satisfied with saddles so my next bike will be a recumbent so I can bike in comfort and speed.Sometimes a saddle may feel great at first but than hurt later on, I really hate that.I agree totally with the ones that say it hurts.
Favorite Trail:
Still exploring
Duration Product Used:
2 Years
Similar Products Used:
Specialized Body Geometry Comp & Sport and Prolong
Giro Vitesse
Coda and a few others
Bike Setup:
Specialized S-worksFSR XC
2 Road Bikes
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Zoe
a Weekend Warrior
from Seattle, WADate Reviewed: May 17, 1999
Strengths:
Very sexy looking, easy off the backWeaknesses:
Ow! Ow ow ow ow ow ow!Bottom Line: I rode the Paola Paezzo / Sella San Marco Bontrager RaceDay saddle, same one different colors: Ow ow ow. Holy heaven I have never had pain like this saddle gave me. It was very cushy for about twenty minutes, then I paid for it for A WEEK. A week!This saddle is very easy to get off the back of; however, dont try to do any road training on it (i.e. SIT on it) or any cross country rides. Its too narrow to perch your sit bones on. Switched to a Serfas Dual Density ARC on reccomendation from a chat site; just as easy to get behind, and actually supports the BONES in my seat. Here's a gossip bit: on one chat site I saw, Juli Furtado (?) popped up explaining that she pulled her name from the saddle since it was so uncomfortable. Fact or fiction? Who can tell?One chili for cool graphics on the Selle Race Day version, and for women with narrower pelvis than mine.
Duration Product Used:
less than 1 month
Similar Products Used:
Serfas Dual Density ARC
Specialized Body Geometry
Various men's saddles
Bike Setup:
Specialized FSR
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
nanc
a cross-country rider
from VADate Reviewed: October 14, 1998
Bottom Line:
liked this saddle for the first 3 months I started riding - great for downhilling given the narrow backend. After getting stronger and riding for longer distances I've discovered it's not as comfortable after all. The seam around the gel portion seems to rub - can you say blisters. i'm not the only woman to have this problem - i know others that quickly switched to another seat after a 3+hour ride on this. If your not in the saddle for a long time very often, and/or your riding is mostly downhill - then it's great. But XC riders might be wise to steer away from this flashy seat.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Cindy
a weekend warrior
from VADate Reviewed: August 16, 1998
Bottom Line:
This saddle is an absolute life-saver!!! After years of riding with my husband, and suffering immeasurably, the first ride with this saddle was completely pain-free. Women, if any of you have ever had a sore nether-region (and you know what I mean), then you should absolutlely get this saddle. I have been riding on it for the past 3 months and LOVE IT!!! Get it and thank me later.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Allison
a
from Burlington, VTDate Reviewed: October 28, 1997
Bottom Line:
The first time that I saw this seat I thought it was the ugliest thing I had ever seen. But after riding the seat that came with my bike and suffering through many uncomfortable rides, I decided that I could deal with the color if it meant that I would be more comfortable riding. I paid $55 for mine on closeout from Supergo. I HIGHLY recommend this seat it is definitely worth the price. And now I actually love the color, it goes great with my bike.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
BROF
a weekend warrior
from Date Reviewed: July 14, 1997
Bottom Line:
My wife just bought this saddle and has been very pleased..extremely cush
on the cooch. Alot of people dont seem to like the color ,I guess it depends
your invidual bike. It looks trick with her proflex. hope Julie pulls through o.k.
we nicknamed it the Fur-taco saddle...I know Im a pervert.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Sharon
a cross-country rider
from NilesDate Reviewed: July 3, 1997
Bottom Line:
This saddle is way too narrow in the rear to be comfortable for a woman's anatomy. It's got the very same rear shape as the men's Bontrager and I suspect it is is the same saddle just with a shorter nose with a hole in it. Also the price is way too high. For $80 bucks you should be getting ti-rails NOT cromoly! Guy's can buy ti-kevlar Flites for $65 so why do they charge woman soo much for this saddle? And the color scheme looks like urban grafitti.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Biker Betty
a weekend warrior
from Vancouver USADate Reviewed: July 2, 1997
Bottom Line:
This seat is totally awesome. It is so gentle on my pooter, I can't imagine my life (sex, love, or otherwise) without it, and yes, my male friend is writing this for me.But seriously, I love this seat. It makes the long rides seem much shorter. Due to the increased comfort, I find I can ride faster and longer than with a traditional (read: designed for men) saddle. Unlike other women's saddles, the Juli is narrow enough for me to slip off the back on technical downhills.Though the color can be considered obnoxious, it goes very well with the rear triangle and all the high zoot yellow stuff on my Litespeed Obed FS.!Oh, that there were
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Ruby
a weekend warrior
from Seattle, WADate Reviewed: July 1, 1997
Bottom Line:
This saddle was not the most comfortable saddle I've ever ridden. It's built for women who are narrowly built through the hips (and I don't mean in contrast of overweight women - I mean in contrast to women who have a wider bone structure!) I posted an earlier note with a less than complimentary review, and that note, along with a few other not so positive reviews of the saddle have mysteriously disappeared from this board. I'm curious how that might have occurred!
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Tracey Hempel
a cross-country rider
from St. Pete, FLDate Reviewed: January 2, 1997
Bottom Line:
I've ridden my share of saddle: road and off-road, and this by far is the best saddle I have every laid my bottom on. Although not bulky, the cushioning is superb and the comfort excellent. It is well worth the expense, and should be mandatory on any woman's bike.Husbands,SO's: If you're trying to get your wive/girlfriends into riding get them this seat. The added comfort will make biking much more enjoyable for them.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
Angie
a cross-country rider
from St. Louis, MODate Reviewed: December 5, 1996
Bottom Line:
I bought this with some hesitance that an $80 seat would really give me
$80 worth of cush. After one technical descent I was convinced that it
was well worth the money I had spent. I had used the Terry prior to this
saddle and the Julie seat was a hundred times better! I can ride on this
seat all day.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
julie
a cross-country rider
from hawaiiDate Reviewed: December 2, 1996
Bottom Line:
a bit expensive, the color is obnoxious, but the ride is nice. Have only had it for less than a month, but is the most comfortable women's seat that I've tried. Had a couple of women's saddles, the previous was a Terry mountain saddle. The Terry was fairly comfortable (and light), but juli's model is definitely the choice for technical riding and comfort.
Overall Rating:
Submitted by
j-me
a cross-country rider
from kansasDate Reviewed: August 20, 1996
Bottom Line:
This is the best saddle ever. For $90, you'll get a saddle that will make long,
bumpy rides almost as comfortable as pavement. With just enough padding,
without going overboard, there is nothing this saddle doesn't offer. With
kevlar protection, this seat is pretty, too. Yellow, black and red make it
a great addition to any bike. Women will enjoy the great padded protection
this saddle offers on long rides. You would never know you've been riding
four hours after dismounting. It does sound a little expensive, but it's
well worth it. With tubular cro-moly rails and a great no-slip system, there
is positively no reason any women shouldn't make the investment. I wouldn't
sit my bottom on anything else.
|
Reviews 1 - 15 (15 Reviews Total)
| |
Review Options:
Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating |
