The Five is a slightly scaled down brother to the Juicy Seven(tm). But even without Pad Contact Point Adjustment, the Five is still head and shoulders above any of the other hydros because of the Avid® blood that runs in the whole Juicy family.
Strengths: I have had my Juicy 5s for about 5 years now. They have been fairly maintenance free and still work just as well as they did the day I bought them. They're really easy to bleed.
Weaknesses: Not enough power or adjustment.
Bottom Line:
Overall, these brakes have served me well for the time that I have had them. I upgraded the hoses that came on them and have bled them a few times and changed the pads. I've never had any serious issues with them other than a little air getting in the lines once a few years ago.
Similar Products Used: Avid Elixir 5, Avid Elixir CR
Bike Setup: Niner EMD, X.9/X.0 drivetrain, Fox F29, White Industries/Stan's wheelset
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
BG
a Weekend Warrior
Date Reviewed: December 9, 2012
Strengths: They stop fantastically...once, they won't release.
Weaknesses: Can't adjust.
Bottom Line:
Had these on a bike I bought, and have been a pain in the ass the whole time. They bite and won't let go. i've had them serviced and week later, the same thing. Climbing hills is hard enough without the brake permanately on!
Weaknesses: I've had issues with these brakes for as long as I've had them. For starters, they're a pain to align. They also are very spongy. As others have noted they need to be bled frequently. They are also a huge pain to bleed. I'm looking for a replacement set after messing with these for way too long.
Bottom Line:
1 chili on the overall rating for all the problems I've had, and 1 chili because no matter how cheap you get them they aren't worth spending any money on.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
grant191
a Cross Country Rider
from st louis mo
Date Reviewed: January 30, 2012
Strengths: great mid level brake set, good starter set to get into the hydro world. stop on a dime and require little maintenance
Weaknesses: they "growl like a turkey" when new, but found after broke in. to re adjust the calipers and I clean the rotors after every ride with rubbing alcohol and they remain quiet
Bottom Line:
good set of brakes even though there are newer models available
Submitted by
norcorider95
a Downhiller
from London, England
Date Reviewed: December 11, 2011
Strengths: urm, not really that many, its okay i guess, very average, nothing special, i suppose it has good modulation. cheap too, also replacement parts are easy to find.
Weaknesses: pads wore down quickly, cheap hose came stock, leaver moves up and down, hard and complicated to bleed, no leaver adjustments, doesnt look that great, need bleeding a lot, spongy. Pistons and seals broke on mine.
Bottom Line:
Average, if its in a sale then go for it buy it, but be prepared to spend a lot on it, pads need replacing about once per month, need bleeding about once every 2 months because they get spongy quickly.
Might be worth getting an elixir 5 or something, maybe more pricey but in the end will work out cheaper.
Similar Products Used: elixir 3, shimano deore m575.
Bike Setup: Specialized big hit fsr 1 2010 with marz 66's, fox dhx 3, hope pro 2 hubs, mavic ex729 rim, crankbros 5050x pedals, sunline bars, nukeproof seat, holzfeller cranks, gravity stem, avid elixir brakes,E13 ls1+ chain device
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
GR
a Cross Country Rider
from Alexandria, VA
Date Reviewed: October 31, 2011
Strengths: Great Stopping Power when wet.
Weaknesses: Brake Drag that keeps reoccuring.
Bottom Line:
Brake drag on rear brake since bike was new. After a year of working trying to fix it the bike shop got Avid to replace both brakes. Started dragging again a month later. Then it stopped for a year of commuting including including in foul weather. Started dragging again, had tune, still dragging. If you get a used bike with these brakes, spin the wheel and see if there is any drag, if so I would not buy, there is no long lasting fix. I will not buy another bike with Avid brakes
Submitted by
Trails-of-Fire
a Weekend Warrior
from San Antonio TX
Date Reviewed: August 8, 2011
Strengths: Good breaking power. Quiet- even when wet. Never have problems with dragging like some users describe happening. Okay my back does in one spot due to my bent rotor which was my fault. Two piece clamp allows removal with removing grips.
Weaknesses: There are better, and more expensive, hydro brakes out there on the market.
Bottom Line:
Look, you can go really expensive on hydro disk brakes and you can also go really cheap. However the Juicy 5's are middle-of-the-road brakes. Don't be fooled by negative posts. There you have it.
Submitted by
robpink
a Weekend Warrior
from England
Date Reviewed: August 4, 2011
Strengths: levers are nice, don't have to take grips off. Look neat!
Weaknesses: where to start.... The levers rattle, no pad adjustment, CONSTANT RUBBING!! i adjust them, then they just rub again after 5 minutes!!!
The noise of the brake is as people describe a 'turkey gobble'.
Not enough power, my old LX discs were way better.
The weird mounting system, that makes it impossible to align the calliper.
Rusty discs.
Bottom Line:
as mentioned, so many issues.
If you have them and get on with them, fine.
If you're thinking of buying them, steer clear! Get shimano, never had a problem with them ever.
Bike Setup: Haro ics 4.0 2003 almost all SRAM components. WTB dual duty wheels. Avid Juicy 5 160mm front and back.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
drdreas
a Weekend Warrior
from Corte Madera Ca. USA
Date Reviewed: July 7, 2011
Strengths: -they stop the bike from moving when i pull the levers
-decent looks
Weaknesses: -they rub constantly! i have to adjust the calipers after every couple of rides to temporarily reduce the rubbing, but it returns again.
-rear brake makes a turkey gobble sound and sends heavy vibrations through the whole bike.
-LOUD!! when i ride down my relatively steep driveway, the sound is tremendous. its like a fcuking air-raid siren or something. so loud in fact that my neighbors have called me out on it before. this is embarrassing, and i expect better from a high end brake system.
-rotors are prone to warping
Bottom Line:
-if you already have them, upgrading isn't a necessity. they work, and for most people, thats what matters.
-if you are gonna buy a bike that comes equipped with them, go ahead and buy it. just be warned that they are NOT flawless, and will need your attention in the future.
-if you are planning on buying these by themselves, DON'T!
Similar Products Used: first pair of disc brakes that i've owned.
Bike Setup: 2008 stumpjumper fsr comp
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
mackienz
a Cross Country Rider
from nz
Date Reviewed: February 18, 2011
Strengths: reasonable power
Weaknesses: They don't have enough stopping power, so your arms get burned out on long descents. also they lack finesse. when i am going down technical twisty rocky steep sections i want smooth breaking, but these would just grip and release throwing my balance off.
Submitted by
jharness
a Cross Country Rider
from colorado springs
Date Reviewed: November 1, 2010
Strengths: worked well except pads can fall out
Weaknesses: my rear brake pads keep falling out
Bottom Line:
the brake pads are held in by a spring I have replaced the pads four times and put new springs in but the brake pad can and does fall out on down hills. One second my brakes are working great the next I have only one rear brake pad.
I will only use brakes with a retaining pin from now on price isn't an issue compared to saftey.
Submitted by
fourgensaz
a Cross Country Rider
from Glendale, AZ, USA
Date Reviewed: September 15, 2010
Strengths: Good braking when it counts. Looks good.
Weaknesses: Break pad rub. Brakes do not "self ajust"! Brake pads fell out completly on two different occasions during races.
Bottom Line:
Waiting for a phone call from LBS to have new Avid BB7 mechanical disc brakes finished installing. This is the only flaw with the above bike I have noticed in 2.5 years of riding it and several hundred miles on the trail.
Similar Products Used: first time using Hydraulic disk brakes
Bike Setup: 2008 Trek fuel EX8 (http://www.trekbikes.com/us/en/bikes/2008/archive/fuelex8)
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Jacques Pienaar
a Weekend Warrior
from Santiago, Chile, SA
Date Reviewed: July 27, 2010
Strengths: Easy to set up, Easy to maintain, Stopping ability/power, availability of service parts etc.
Weaknesses: None noted so far
Bottom Line:
These brakes came with the bicycle I purchased just over a year ago. In this period I have covered around 2175 miles of All Mountain riding and have experienced no issues with these brakes. I have gone down some gnarly downhill runs at local ski resorts with some high speed techy stuff and these brakes have only saved my @ss more than once. Great stopping power, getting the job done. Not the top of the line and limited adjustment settings but when you need them to stop you in time, the result is actually impressive. Great quality, great value