Review Options:
Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating |
|
Reviews 1 - 9 (9 Reviews Total)
| |
User Reviews
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
coconuthugger
a Cross Country Rider
from Klamath falls,OregonDate Reviewed: August 16, 2009
Strengths: I have owned a Scott spark ltd for two years now with no problems at all I weigh in at 185 and have had no problems with bike being fragile or dt swiss fork being spongy or flexing. I do not know what the guy in europe is talking about?Ilive in a high desert area with plenty of rock gardens everywhere in fact!!I also clock in about 65 miles of single track a month on very rough terrain!!! come on up to Klamath Falls,Oregon I will be happy to show you what I am talking about.The bike is bad ass!! Now I want the Scott genius ltd!!!Weaknesses: None in two years.Bottom Line: If I had a complaint it would be the clearcoat on all carbon mtb frames where as maybe its just cosmetic it still sucks when your beautiful multi thousand dollar frame is scratched the f@@k up!
Favorite Trail: Jack rabbit
Duration Product Used: 2 Years
Price Paid:
$8900.00
Purchased At: lbs
Similar Products Used: Moots ybb,scott spark 30,Klein adroit,Kona sex one.
Bike Setup: Full xtr.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Scott-skeptic?
a Cross Country Rider
from EuropeDate Reviewed: July 28, 2009
Strengths: Lightweight, adjustable rear travel (traction control), Remote lockout both front&rear, equipment mixWeaknesses: Overly lightweight/fragile, DT forkBottom Line: At 72 kg (160 Lbs) I am no heavyweight, but the frame gave up on me just the other day...When everything works the bike feels fine, except for the stock DT XCR fork, which is no mach for a Fox F series or RS Reba performance - it feels just like the first SID that came out ages ago - spongy and flexy.
Otherwise I think it is a shame for a serious company to jeopardize bikes safety and integrity to gain 100 grams or even less!
Also I think this bike is overpriced!
Will go for a solid bike NEXT time!
Duration Product Used: 6 months
Bike Setup: Stock
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
espanolie
a Cross Country Rider
from Pasadena, CADate Reviewed: June 24, 2009
Strengths: Solid Climber
Strong Descents
Lightweight
Carbon Strength
Beautiful Finish in Black and Carbon
Versatile for many types of trailsWeaknesses: Black finish is delicate, especially on a mountain bike with a lot of possible debris to scratch/damage frame setBottom Line: I have been riding a Giant MTB for several years matched to Sram X7 rear derailleur and shifters along with other Shimano XT components. I was ready for an upgrade.
I did a lot of reasearch on this website (mountainbikereview.com) reading and rereading articles about so many frame sets from Cannondale, Specialized, Trek, Giant and Scott. I was most impressed with Scott as they had a model with everything I was looking for pretaining to build and components. It certainly saved the trouble of building it myself. Besides, everyone has a Specialized or Trek - honestly, be different! From my short experience with this bike, it certainly is noticed and admired by others I find on the trail including those owning what I was comparing it to.
I bought my 2008 Scott Spark Limited used from the internet. The Seller claimed to have ridden it only a few times. After inspecting it upon arrival, I believed him. It was in near perfect condition. I realize I paid less than half the retail price, which was a great blessing to me. It was at my doorstep days before Thanksgiving 2008.
Though I'm not a professional rider by any means, I certainly consider myself an avid mountain bike cyclist. I like the change of pace from my road bike experiences. Riding in the drizzle, soft sprinkle or shortly after a rainstorm is my favorite times to ride. I love kicking up the mud!
My Scott Spark Limited rides like a dream! It climbs increibly well. I've played around with the lock out features for both shocks, and find it useful though not necessary. But since it's a remote lockout and so conveniently located on my bars, at first I used it all the time. Now, with the newness wearing off, I now use them periodically.
At first, I was concerned how it would handle downhills and its speed, since it weighs in at just a tick under 21 pounds complete with pedals. The DT Swiss XRC700 only has about 4 inches of travel while the DT Swiss rear shock has about the same travel of 4 inches or possibly less. Let me tell you, now that I've had over six months of enjoying my ride, downhill, uphill, jumps and turning in higher speeds is absolutely no problem for this machine. In fact, I have a trail not far from my house I would complete in my older bike, a Giant, in about 43 minutes. It's a narrower fire road with 7-10% grade climbs with a few bumps for fun. In my Scott Spark Limited, the same ride is done in 36 minutes. Bike alone I lost almost 10 pounds! You be the judge.
The frame is strong and stiff. I find it very responsive when I turn in tight corners as well as the long descents as I build speed. On the bumps and jumps, I dial in the shocks at a moderate setting and it's plenty for me, though I weigh 162.
The Sram XO components are a great compliment to the frame and shock component choices of DT Swiss make it a great performer. The Magura Marta SL brake set is crazy strong. While going down hill, I only use one finger to press the lever enough to slow down or stop.
This complete build will set you back retail of at least $8k. That's a lot for any bike, which is the lowest I saw on the internet brand new for this model. I've seen it also as high as $12k, brand new.
For my modest investment for what I received, I know I got a steal. I was at the right place at the right price. And now, I'm enjoying it to the fullest!
Favorite Trail: Marshall Canyon
Duration Product Used: 6 months
Price Paid:
$4000.00
Purchased At: On-Line
Similar Products Used: Giant
Bike Setup: DT Swiss XRC700 Carbon Fork with remote lockout
DT Swiss Rear Shock with remote lockout
Sram XO Shift Levers
Sram XO Rear Derailleur
Shimano XTR Front Derailleur
TruVativ Carbon Crankset
Magura Marta SL compelte brake set
Look Quartz Carbon Ti Pedals
Ritchey Carbon Headset
Ritchey Carbon Seat Clamp
Scott Spark Limited Pilot SL Carbon Bar/Stem combo
WTB Devo Carbon Saddle
Continental King Tires
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
fabini
a Cross Country Rider
from miamiDate Reviewed: March 5, 2009
Strengths: maneuverability is just amazing-extremely responsive-lightweight to say the least.you control this bike so easily it actually lets you get out of near falls more easily.Weaknesses: priceyBottom Line: if you can afford it go for it-you'll be riding a dream bike.
Favorite Trail: oleta
Duration Product Used: 3 months
Price Paid:
$8000.00
Purchased At: bigwheels
Bike Setup: scott ltd 09'frame-full xtr-dt swiss fork-dt swiss carbon wheels-formula R1 brakes-selle carbon saddle-schwalbe tires
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
ScottSparkman
a Cross Country Rider
from Chicago, IL, USADate Reviewed: March 11, 2008
Strengths: I was worried that it would be fragile ... but it is not. This bike is not only light, but very sturdy. Originally, we found a couple screws in the suspension that liked to loosen themselves every 4 hours or so. I little blue lock-tight and a torque wrench and I haven't heard a single noise since. This bike is light an solid.Weaknesses: I bought the Spark 30 so I could tailor some of the components to my tastes. I added the Ritchey WCS Carbon handlebars and a Ritchey WCS Carbon stem. The faceplate of my stem is carbon, better (cooler looking) than the one that comes on the OEM version. The wheels are a bit weak and I plan to replace them with some ZTR or Crossmax ST wheels. I also added the XTR front derailleur and I'm thinking about the X.O. rear derailleur. I guess I could have bought the Spark 20 instead of doing it myself. The Scott tires that came on it sucked. In one ride on a flat, rolling riverside trail I got three (3) flat tires! They were too thin for any regular use. It's tempting to become a weight weenie while owning one of these. Seriously, all of the weaknesses are pretty minor.Bottom Line: This bike kicks rear. It's light. It's solid. It's fast. It's available at pretty good prices now that it's been around for a year. The general layout of the cockpit is good and probably won't need much adjustment for most riders. And ... it has a lot of wow-factor built in.
Favorite Trail: there's a local trail, technically illegal, but been there for years - Rosie's Bumps
Duration Product Used: 1 Year
Price Paid:
$4000.00
Purchased At: Higher Gear
Similar Products Used: This is the nicest of all my past bikes. Giant Warp DS1 with all upgraded components. Specialized FSR. Santa Cruz Superlight D, also with upgrades.
Bike Setup: Spark 30. Ritchey WCS Carbon riser bars with a 100 mm Ritchey WCS Carbon stem. I also found the Ritchey carbon 34.9 seatpost. I've added Crank Bros Acid 2 pedals and Hutchinson Python Light tires.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Mark
a Cross Country Rider
from Tucson Arizona USADate Reviewed: February 17, 2008
Strengths: Scary lightweight, XC capable, full-suspensionWeaknesses: Weren't we all here back in 1998?Bottom Line: It's a great ride. Very light, about 23 pounds in the larger frame, with four-inches-plus of suspension travel. My AMP B-5 did all of this back in 1998, with aluminum and titanium instead of carbon fiber, but it's nice to see that light F/S XC bikes are back.
Ride is good, well damped but noticeably stiffer than the old AMP, which had coil/oil shocks front (RockShox) and rear (AMP). Most likely this is probably due to the air-damped rear shock and fork. No doubt the C/F frame as well. Feels a little stiff when braking or accelerating (could be the seatstay pivot), compared to the AMP. I'm used to plush, lightweight F/S bikes, and don't see the need for the short-travel adjustment.
Bottom line: The right way to build a bike. Why aren't there more bikes like these, who needs 32+ pounds to lug around.
Duration Product Used: Tested or demo'ed only
Similar Products Used: 1998 AMP B-5 XC F/S
Bike Setup: Factory
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
boris alspaugh
a Cross Country Rider
from georgetown,co.Date Reviewed: November 23, 2007
Strengths: balanced and lively, excellent power transfer. l ikes to go forward. intergrated post.Weaknesses: needs fatter tiresBottom Line: fast and efficient-likes to be hammered-
Favorite Trail: twisted sister
Duration Product Used: 1 Year
Price Paid:
$6000.00
Purchased At: the bike dr.
Similar Products Used: ransom-heckler-air9-scale10
Bike Setup: stock large---xtr-reba sl -xtr wheels
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
william shott
a Cross Country Rider
from golden coloradoDate Reviewed: November 10, 2007
Strengths: it's mine.Weaknesses: Other people can buy it too...Bottom Line: Don't get it- it climbs too much like a hard tail and then (if you choose to flip a lever) will scare you with how fast and smooth it descends.
Ever since I got it I've been dissapointed with how much faster I am riding my usual loops. Don't know what to do while I wait at the trail head for everyone to catch up.
Oh yeah, and it's HEAVY... for a roadbike.
Seriously though- despite the travel it's not a free ride or traily, but if you know what your max wattage is... uh oh.
Favorite Trail: all things single
Duration Product Used: 3 months
Similar Products Used: trek fuel, moots ybb, etc.
Bike Setup: full xtr, 160 f and b rotore,rockshox reba WC fork, ritchey bar and stem, Reba WC fork, crank bros peds, and SI SLR saddle.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Scott
a Racer
from TexasDate Reviewed: June 6, 2007
Strengths: Lightweight as advertised. 3-way rear shock has been very useful on different courses. Easy setup.Weaknesses: Bike arrived with a blown rear shock, DT Swiss replaced it immediately.Bottom Line: Home run. Excellent full suspension platform that performs as well or better as my previous ride but 3 lbs lighter. Attracts lots of attention, attention to detail is supurb. Had to wait 4 months to get it, but worth it.
Duration Product Used: Less than 1 month
Purchased At: Sponsor shop
Similar Products Used: Titus Racer X
Bike Setup: Standard except for Eggbeater triple ti pedals and Maxxis Crossmark non-UST tires
|
Reviews 1 - 9 (9 Reviews Total)
| |
Review Options:
Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating |