Product DescriptionSurly is known for creating strong fatTire bikes. They debutedThe Pugsley a few years back and it was an instant hit.The PugsleyTook you placesThat a standard bike couldn’t. However,There are places and conditionsThat require an even larger footprint.Therefore,The Moonlander was created. The heart ofThe Moonlander isThe 4130 CroMoly steel, which you’ll find every Surly bike is made of.The Moonlader features 135mm- space, 28mm- offset, rear- loading Surly horizontal dropouts (tra
Review Options: Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating
|Reviews 1 - 8 (8 Reviews Total)|
Date Reviewed: November 21, 2014
Strengths: Monster truck equivalent bike. Rolls over just about everything that's hard and floats over everything else that's soft. The larger tires make a big difference going over sand, gravel, snow and stair steps. Once you get it rolling it is easy to maintain momentum. In the right conditions it can even handle sloppy mud conditions by giving you a stable platform to power through slippery muck. I can also say as a trail finder/maker this has no bicycle equal. It can charge over tall grass, uneven dirt and light brush without a blink. With a pair of 45NRTH Husker Du tires this thing becomes an ice machine. I fit it out with their pogies and the studded tires and never miss a beat. Only when the snow gets very thick and very powdery does the bike have trouble. Dropping the tire pressure doesn't overcome the plowing effect when the snow pack is light and fluffy. Not necessarily unique to this bike but the extra footprint doesn't get you past the physics problem with lesser fatbikes. It does float wonderfully over the fluffy powdery sand common along bayous near the gulf coast.
Weaknesses: ...however, in the wrong conditions this thing can become a swamp monster clogged with mud, sticks and all manner of sticky, heavy muck. I ride on mainly flat open steppe in central Asia where trails are few and conditions change dramatically. Just the right mix of dirt and water can conjure up several extra kgs of mud that will bring you to a virtual halt. The geometries don't provide a lot of clearance with a full size tire (5"-ish) so the benefits of the footprint for ground control dissipate when the mud grabs hold of the sidewalls.
I went with a full bike kit circa early 2013 and would agree the build is weak compared to the potential of the bike. Lower end shifters, weaker brakes and other components make the ride less enjoyable off the shelf. I'll ride until things start to wear out and replace with much better kit.
Price Paid: $2300.00
Purchased At: West End Bicycles -
Date Reviewed: November 4, 2014
Strengths: I love the Moonlander. It is easier to handle and ride than my full suspension MB. Climbs everything. Rolls over downed trees. Just as fast as my mountain bike. The sand trails in this area are easy on this bike. Fun to ride. Mine came in at 34 lbs abd feels light to peddle. MB 32 lbs. i have racks and pannies for it and have done three winter weekend tours.
Weaknesses: After one and a half winters and two summers the wheels are loose and need adjustment. The head tube came loose as well and has to be replaced. The front brake was much too weak and I put a larger disk on it with better brake pads. An expensive upgrade that should have been designed better in a bike of this price.
Duration Product Used: 2.5 years
Purchased At: Bike Zone
Similar Products Used: Mountain bike
Bike Setup: Very low gearing
Date Reviewed: December 15, 2013
Strengths: Just went over 10 miles on trails covered in 3 - 8 inches of snow in -1 degree temp. The bike performed flawlessly despite the cold. I run 5.5 psi in front and 7.5 psi in back and had great traction; although, in the deepest snow over 6" the back tire spun a lot but I moved forward. Last month I took it out mugging and it went through 6' of greasy Iron County, WI mud, over bever dams, and rocky logging trails.
Weaknesses: None. The weight is expected on a bike this size and is necessary for strength.
Date Reviewed: September 30, 2013
Strengths: The bike is fun. Plain and simple. Traction is in a league of its own. Though the bike is heavy, the traction negates some of that, especially on climbs. Frame geometry is the most comfortable I have ever felt on a bike. Makes long rides easier to handle. The components on the Moonlander are great too. It shifts like butter and cable brakes are better than some hydraulic brakes I have had. Tires are stupidly fat. And yea, that is a strength.
Weaknesses: Not too many weaknesses. Some might think 36 lbs is heavy, and it is, but like others have said, it does not feel heavy. When in the granny gear the chain rubs the rear tire a bit. I can’t feel it ever but I can see the scuffs left by the chain on the tire. Lettering on the bike is just decals. The “moonlander” logo on the top tube has already rubbed off of mine (because of my bike rack holding it where the letters are). A tad too expensive I think.
Date Reviewed: August 8, 2013
Strengths: This is my first fatty and I purchased the complete bike and what a pure joy to ride! I waited 4.5 months for it and it was well worth the wait and has easily handled everything I have been able to throw at it so far. The components were apparently upgraded by Surly, the friction shift is gone and now has indexed shifting and it shifts and stops just fine for me however I did have to tweak the brake handles for they were a little spongy.
Weaknesses: In the lowest gears, you can get some chain rub on the rear tire but that is the nature of this awesome beast.
Duration Product Used: 3 weeks
Price Paid: $2500.00
Purchased At: Local bike shop
Similar Products Used: Road bike and 29'r
Date Reviewed: March 16, 2013
Strengths: Unequalled traction. Visually prominent and outlandish to the public. Reasonably unique and rare as of 2013. Great paintjob. Strong frame even when dropped on bigger pieces of steel ;) (speaking from experience). Offset rims present a great talking point, but its hard to ignore those clownshoe rims and tyres. Very low gearing to allow goat like climbing ability.
Weaknesses: OEM equipment is terrible. No point beating around the bush. Some love the cable pull brakes, but after purchasing two moonlanders I can verify that they are weak, spongey and have difficulty locking up the rear wheel on demand. Have ditched them in favour of 200mm XT hydro discs front and back. No comparison.
Mini shifters? less said the better. Also changed to XT shifters and derailluer.
2012 model has a terrible front hub and non standard bearings. Ripped it off and replaced with Hope hubs front and rear. Went through two freewheel clusters on rear wheel before replacing to hope hubs. I put it down to an inability of the OEM drivetrain to cope with the incredible level of torque offered by the gearing, wider crank and a big guy hammering it constantly. 2013 spec model I have also purchased has a better front hub (std bearings) although a lack of quick release.
Don't let the specifications put you off however, I am a very finicky owner and my opinions may not apply to your bike.
Grips spin easily on handlebars, even when wired on. Rip them off and use an aluminium handgrip with nuts on ends to ensure no movement in wet/muddy conditions.
In the bush it climbs like nothing else. The traction is out of this world and incomparable with anything other than a fatbike or a snow plow. It can ride up stairs. It can ride up walking trails. It can fly down snow slopes like a skier and paddle through rivers (literally while riding!) It rides over rocky riverbeds with consummate ease and will take you to work through peak hour traffic as well.
It is not fast. It is not the quickest around your favorite MTB single track. This is not its intended purpose. It can be ridden fast in the right hands, but its about the fun factor. The bulging tyres absorb sharp rocks and sticks. Obstacles meld into absorbtion mode and you would swear the bike has suspension - but it has none! This absence means hardtail bliss as power is transferred directly to the ground where its needed and pedal to ground clearance remains constant! (No smacking the lower pedal on fast corners).
Truly a game changing bike that I cannot recommend enough. Expensive, yes. Requires upgrading, yes. But as an entry point into a new world of fitness and fun? Priceless.
Bike Setup: 2012 Surly Moonlander
Hope Evo Pro Hubs front and back
XT rear derailluer
XT hydro brakes front and back with 200mm discs
Riser Handlebar (std too low)
10 speed cluster at rear and 20/36t front (22/36 standard)
Lou and Bud rubber - best knobbies ever
Date Reviewed: June 18, 2012
Strengths: The Moonlander is all about the FAT tyre footprint and this it does much better than anything else. It accepts the 4.7 Big Fat Larry's on 100mm Clown Shoe rims with plenty to spare. With the MWOD cranks and radically offset rear hub you also get a chain line that gives you all the gears you need for grinding this bike up the hills in the soft stuff. Riding position is very comfortable and just works?
I'm using this bike in the middle east's deserts and it's changed my whole outlook on where I can ride here, it's virtually unlimited now. Here is a video showing a good example of the bike working in the conditions here http://vimeo.com/43733392
Weaknesses: The level of equipment is relatively low for a $2000 bike (complete). I chose to upgrade with hydralic brakes instead of cable operated and conventional shifters instead of the winter orientated . I've also switched the deore rear mech for an XT shadow mech I had in the spares drawer.
It's also a heavy bike. The tyre/rim combination could never be lightweight, there is just way to much material there for that. The steel frame is built to be ridden a lot and has all the braze-ons you could want for expeditioning in the off the beaten track environments that this bike sucks up with passion but it is no lightweight as a result. I'm going to be looking at ways of potentially losing some weight through upgrading things like stem, bars, post and saddle.
I've tried it, just the once so far, on the single track here in the middle east and it went well but not as well as my conventional FS trail bike + I suffered a couple of punctures due to incorrect tyre pressures I think
And it's a bike that's designed to go places too with all the braze-ons needed for racks, mud guards and cages? I have a frame bag, bar sling and saddle bag on their way to be ready to take the bike exploring this winter.
The way Surly have solved the problems of tyre clearence and chainline by offsetting both the rear triangle AND the spoke layout of the rear wheel is really impressive when you look at it closely. It allows the use of conventional components which again makes sense for a bike designed to go places most bikes can't.
Bottom line is there is no other bike that can run this FAT a tyre/rim combination using relatively conventional parts (only the chainrings are FAT specialist really). If your somewhere where there is plenty of soft riding conditions then no other bike will cope with them as well.
Purchased At: The Bikemonger
Similar Products Used: None- first fat bike
Date Reviewed: May 9, 2012
Strengths: Climbs great, rolls great, rolls over most anything, strong, sparkle paint like a 1980's speed boat, feels surprisingly like a normal mountain bike. I really like the Surly brand. Offset rear end works great. Love the thumb shifters. It is so fun I don't ride my other mountain bikes any more.
Weaknesses: It is heavy when I have to carry it while dismounted but I don't notice the weight when on it. With all fat bikes you need to be able to competently adjust the air pressure to match your terrain. Not hard but necessary. If you do it will ride smooth and be very fast on anything from rough stuff to the road. But if for example you are using too low of air pressure on a hard surface like a road it will ride like your on a drunk elephant.
Price Paid: $2000.00
Purchased At: Hub in Minneapolis
Similar Products Used: Surly Pugsley still own.
Tried Necromancer and both aluminum Mukluks. I did not like the upright feel of the Mukluks on the test rides.
Bike Setup: Stock at this point. I am hoping for big fat husker du tires in the future.
|Reviews 1 - 8 (8 Reviews Total)|
Review Options: Sorted by Latest Review | Sort by Best Rating