Submitted by
Warren Hayes
a Cross Country Rider
from Kidderminster, Worcestershire, England
Date Reviewed: May 24, 2008
Strengths: the frame definitely, sharp rear and a fairly stretched-out front.
Weaknesses: cheap groupset, but at this price its flexible enough to upgrade to the juicier things
Bottom Line:
good solid reliable(mine has done a major tour accross spain in base form as well as countless rough sessions with mates....(al work and no play eh gary) :-)
Weaknesses: The seat is harder than the rocks beside the trail, brakes are a tad weak, front derailleur
Bottom Line:
It's a good frame to start from. Some components aren't great, but what do expcet on a $400 bike? I'm planning on upgrading brakes and fork when i get some dough.
Similar Products Used: old specialized (now resting in pieces)
Bike Setup: Serfas Reactive Gel saddle, Coda supsension seatpost, Michelin Jet rear tire, otherwise stock
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
steve
from Columbus OH USA
Date Reviewed: June 30, 2002
Strengths: An alternative to standard frame geometry without paying boutique prices.
Weaknesses: Plan on getting a saddle that fits you, like you would have to do with any new bike.
Bottom Line:
Test ride the Fisher Genesis line, or Trek's new bikes, to find out what a stretched-out frame geometry feels like (talk 'em in to putting on a longer stem if you have to). If a bike like this fits you, it's a bargain, and the Marlin is about as inexpensive as you can get with this geometry. If it doesn't fit you, there are all the other manufacturers out there making bikes for you. 5 chilis for value. Ignoring price, 3 chilis because this was never meant to be the top-of-the line. The Marlin is a good bike with a frame geometry that is hard to find.
Similar Products Used: I've owned a lot of bikes, and ridden a lot more. Fisher's Genesis geometry is the most stretched-out I've ridden.
Bike Setup: Wheels I built myself. Stretched out the bike even more with a longer stem. Sachs Power Grip Extreme twisties. I'm keeping the low-end Shimano 8-speed drivetrain. Specialized Body Geometry saddle.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Ethan
a Weekend Warrior
from Jersey, USA
Date Reviewed: June 18, 2002
Strengths: Great Frame. Light. Good Handling
Weaknesses: Drivetrain Sucks, replace it with Deore XT. Handlebar breaks and scratches easily. Shocks are crap.
Bottom Line:
This is a great entry level MTB. The drivetrain is horrible but for $200 or so u can get a great one. Must replace shox with some super smooth Bombers.
Submitted by
Andy
a Weekend Warrior
from Ft. Lauderdale, FL
Date Reviewed: January 18, 2002
Strengths: Frame is strong and light weight. The RockShox is fine for 185lb or less riders. Great deal! Upgrade potential! Excelent trail bike!
Weaknesses: Seat sux but I'm dealing with it cause I hardly ever sit on it. Components are a little heavy but at $450 u can upgrade and still have a great bike @ a great price, or my name's not Andy Fisher.
Bottom Line:
Great starter bike! I owned a Gary Fisher Aquilla before this bike and still own it, so now I'll always buy Gary Fisher bikes. The Marlin hangs with the $1000 bikes easily.
Favorite Trail: Markam Park (sick + twisted trails)
Duration Product Used: 6 months
Price Paid:
$450.00
Purchased At: Victoria Bikes
Similar Products Used: Old Cannondale, Gary Fisher Aquilla (still own)
Bike Setup: handbar extentions, water bottle cage, Shimano PD-M545 clippin pedals, i'll eventually get a new seat too.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Joe
a Weekend Warrior
from eugene OR USA
Date Reviewed: January 10, 2002
Strengths: nice frame, OK components, great price preformance ratio. the genises geomitry is great
Weaknesses: the rockshock jetts are substancial to many riders, the seat does suck it was gone the day i bought it. the front mech has gone crapy otherwise fine A great deal
Bottom Line:
great price preformance ratio, good components, over all agood begginer bike.
Strengths: Frame, Price, looks great, solid foundation for upgrading over time, WTB Raptors are a good all-around tire.
Weaknesses: Seat, chessy brake pads, lower end components.
Bottom Line:
Great bike, with a great frame, super stable, feels firm but very controlable, plan to upgrade components this winter to XT, because a frame this good deserves it. Bike takes all you can dish out, and still wants more. Climbs like a billy goat. Bontraiger rims are more than adequate, Boni' bars are super comfortable, and the Rock Shox Jett is quick and one of the reasons a bike this good can be this great of a value.
Similar Products Used: GT, Trek, Cannondale, and older Fisher's
Bike Setup: Selle Italia seat, XT brake pads, stock components, and Shimano ATB pedals.
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Neil A
a Weekend Warrior
from San Diego,CA
Date Reviewed: November 4, 2001
Strengths: LOOK BELOW
Weaknesses: ...
Bottom Line:
I already posted an entry, but just want to caution everyone on the seat...Not only is it hard, but it may break if you hit something as common as a curb too hard. I rode off of a curb and the seat began to shake, click, and the finally the metal post separated and i almost landed flat on my face. BE CAREFUL. I already purchased a new seat, which is a hell of a lot more comfortable too.
Submitted by
Alan Doloboff
a Weekend Warrior
from North Hills, NY
Date Reviewed: November 4, 2001
Strengths: USA MADE $VALUE, $VALUE,$VALUE Lifetime frame guarantee Gary Fisher reputation
Weaknesses: The seat. I took my serfas off of my 15year old Panasonic bike and am much happier as is my butt
Bottom Line:
Tested the TRek 4900 but could not see the rationale for the much higher cost. Since I am not a professional I felt the value of the Marlin coupled with the ability to upgrade makes it a great value. Fantastic geometry, excellent frame and best of all it is "BORN IN THE USA"
Similar Products Used: Test drove Trek and a specialized bike
Bike Setup: stock
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
Ethan
a Weekend Warrior
from Philly, PA
Date Reviewed: October 18, 2001
Strengths: Genesis Geometry--especially for taller riders (I am 6'2"), light and strong frame for the price, Gary Fisher lifetime frame guarantee, solid components for entry-level bike
Weaknesses: RockShox fork bottoms out for heavier riders on aggressive trails, horrible seat (replace before leaving the store), questionable tires for wet surfaces
Bottom Line:
If you are not willing to spend $1000+, you should buy this bike hands down. And even with those expen$ive bikes, you will get 15% better components for 2x the price. Especially if you are just getting into mountain biking, the Marlin is the way to go. The frame is easily upgadable as well. Don't take my word for it--ride one and you'll understand.
Similar Products Used: Crappy Costco Motiv Groundpounder. HORRIBLE BIKE. return the day after i bought it.
Bike Setup: water bottle holder, new seat
Overall Rating:
Value Rating:
Submitted by
KC
a Weekend Warrior
from Long Island, NY, USA
Date Reviewed: September 8, 2001
Strengths: Don't know yet
Weaknesses: Don't know yet
Bottom Line:
Bottom Line: choice between the Fisher Marlin for $350 and a Trek Alpha 4300 for $320. I'll be using it for weekend trail-riding, nothing professional, etc.
Any advice? Right now I'm leaning toward the Fisher; seems lighter, and seems to have a slightly better review here. Thanks.
Submitted by
Steve Thorp
a Weekend Warrior
from Lubbock, TX
Date Reviewed: August 10, 2001
Strengths: Great quality for the money, lightweight, extremely stable. The best value I could find in the sub $600 market.
Weaknesses: ft. fork....this is my first ft. shok'd bike, and the jett is softer than my buddies Wal-Mart special.
Bottom Line:
No hills here to speak of, so it's all urban. I really like the balance of the bike, and the only things I would change are the ft. fork(far too soft, and I'm only 180lbs.), seat, and tires(great for offroad, but lugz are a little agressive for concrete)